FEDERAL GOVERNMENTS RESPONSE TO ENQUIRY
At the end of July,2004, the Federal Government made its first public
response to the “shared parenting inquiry” recommendations, issued at the end of
That day, the Courier Mail committed four (4) pages to articles on the
matter, leaving no doubt that Family Law has very much returned to the social
and political centre stage.
The Federal Government’s response was released by way of “a discussion paper”
and immediately criticised by the opposition for being just a discussion paper
proposal, rather than as policy. Regardless, there appears little likelihood
that the proposed reforms will be considered for implementation until after the
The Inquiry recommendations were extensive and radical, proposing amongst
other things, a national system of Tribunals to replace the Family Court. One
media commentator has referred to the discussion paper as “a strangely muted
response to the Parliamentary Inquiry”.
In summary, the discussion paper suggests:
- enshrining the concept of “shared parenting responsibility” in
- effecting legislative changes to acknowledge that children have a right to
spend time on a regular basis with both of their Parents and that both Parents
have to be consulted before significant discussions are made about a child’s
care, welfare and development, except in cases involving violence, child abuse
or entrenched conflict;
- legislative amendments being made, to ensure that Parents try to resolve
disputes through alternative dispute resolution and the development of a
Parenting Plan before filing actions with the Court;
- the creation of a network of 65 community based Family Relationship
Centres across Australia to provide separating Parents with up to three (3)
hours of free dispute resolution sessions. The Centres to assess each case,
offer assistance in developing a Parenting Plan, provide information and
advice and screen for instances of child abuse or violence, in which case, the
couples would be referred to other Government support services, or the Courts;
- people using the Centres would be able to bring only friends and family,
not Lawyers, along to the meetings, for support;
- establishing a Task Force to review the methods used to calculate and
administer Child Support payments and to report back by March, 2005 , for
- legislative amendments to recognise the entitlement of family members (who
are not Parents) to contact, such as, Grandparents;
- a new combined Registry for the Family Court and the Federal Magistrates
- that the 65 community based Family Relationship Centres would be funded by
the Government, but tendered for and run by community and church groups who
already offer similar services.
The opposition spokesman stated that the Federal Opposition was likely to
support the changes to the Family Law system if they were brought before the
Parliament because they appeared to be in the best interests of children and
If the discussion paper does eventuate into real legislative change, its
impact will depend upon the specifics of the legislative change. From the broad
statements made at this stage, the writer would question whether it will
ultimately result in any manifest difference to the current system.
The legislative amendments contemplated for parental responsibility and for
grandparents contact are already contained in the legislation as “objects”.
Furthermore, in promoting primary dispute resolution, it is noted that the
Family Law Rules were amended in March, 2004 to provide that alternative dispute
resolution is a compulsory “Pre-Action Procedure” prior to any Court Application
being filed. The contemplated establishment of 65 community based Family and
Relationship Centres would assist in clarifying the appropriate alternative
dispute resolution process.
The history of “Parenting Plans” since 1996, has shown that they have been
poorly received by the community as options for dealing with child, Residence
and Contact arrangements.
The reality remains, as quoted by a client, “Mediation only works if two
people want it to work”
Last modified on Aug 26, 2004 12:12:33 PM by Michael Lynch Family Lawyers.
This Information Outline is provided courtesy of Michael Lynch Family Lawyers
who are accredited specialists in this area of law. They are located at Level
17, 255 Adelaide Street, Brisbane, QLD 4000 or call them on (07) 3221-4300 if
you would like more information on this legal topic, or you wish to obtain
formal advice regarding your situation.
The core values of Michael Lynch Family Lawyers are: that no two people are
alike, everyone is unique; to exercise professional integrity with all people we
deal with; and a commitment to excellence in client care and client service.
These values and looking after clients well, has enabled Michael Lynch Family
Lawyers to provide a highly regarded Specialist Family Law service. With our
professional staff consisting of three Accredited Specialists and a total of six
professional staff (with combined family law experience of over 50 years), all
dedicated solely to Family Law, we are one of the largest Specialist Family Law
Firms in Queensland. Our combined Family Law experience enables Michael Lynch
Family Lawyers to provide expert and focused advice that is sensitive to the
many financial, social and emotional issues experienced in Family Law.